The Inside Track: Too Good To Be True


In this issue of The Inside Track, Hilary Bradt shares a recent experience with an AI-powered email scam. Reflecting on past deceptions, she considers the erosion of trust and the value of genuine human connection.

***

I was slumped on a National Express bus, tired out of my mind after an overnight flight from Brazil, but scrolling sleepily through all the emails that had been blocked while I was abroad.

Then…

What was that?

An email from Elizabeth Strout?

Must be the subject line – I often discuss favourite authors with friends – so scrolled back.

No, it was from the famous American author herself, stating how much she’d enjoyed my book, ​Taking the Risk​, and claiming that she had some questions for me.

She had obviously read it carefully.

I figured that this surely must be some sort of scam - though where was the gain?

When I was home, I googled various possibilities but was reassured that no comedian had ever impersonated Elizabeth Strout, and that no scam associated with her had been logged. So I chose to believe it, forwarded it elatedly to friends and relations, and replied gushingly. For two days I was cock-a-hoop with delight and pride.

It was Adrian Phillips, Managing Director at Bradt, who told me very gently and carefully that he thought this was a scam, and that he could recognise some signs of AI in the way the letter was worded. So, I did some more precise googling and, yes, it was confirmed.

I was bitterly disappointed and very, very embarrassed. How could I be conceited enough to think that such a well-known author would contact me?

Within a couple of weeks I had received four other different approaches, all of whom ‘came across’ my book (the phrase ‘Elizabeth’ used) and wanted to give me wonderful publicity or link me up with an American book club. Every email used the tell-tale phrase ‘came across’ and all were sent from a Gmail address. I understood that eventually money would be requested, but it takes a few exchanges to get to that point. Of course, if AI is responsible, there’s no time wasted for the instigator.

Still mystified at what the scammer had to gain, I decided to play along.

My next letter to ‘Elizabeth’ focused on what she was working on. The response came within hours – a clear scam giveaway – but was most beguiling, telling me a lot about her current writings, reflecting on the Strout book I was currently reading and asking me more questions. I would have so enjoyed this correspondence had it been genuine! But I let a week pass. The nuanced, interesting replies were replaced by an unsigned, vague email which happened to be identical to one sent by another scammer I was ignoring. Had I not responded, I suspect the emails would have stopped, but they contained a message I couldn’t resist answering creatively:

Also, with Halloween here, I wanted to wish you a Happy Halloween! 🎃👻 I hope your day is filled with happiness, laughter, and a little spooky fun!

I responded:

You ask about Halloween, and I must say I’m embracing this American festival! I seem to have acquired a large number of young friends and relations, a bit like Rabbit in Winnie the Pooh, so we all went down to the beach dressed as witches, zombies and monsters, and most of us ended up in the sea which is still warm after the beautiful summer we’ve had. Tonight I shall give in to my small neighbours June and Rachel’s pleading and take them trick or treating. Never done it before so fingers crossed we only come across nice people!

My neighbour Rachel is 93 and June is in her 70s. We hate Halloween. And I don’t know any kids.

And sure enough, the response was:

Your Halloween adventure sounds absolutely delightful! I love the image of everyone dressed as witches, zombies, and monsters heading down to the beach, only to end up in the sea. It sounds like a celebration full of laughter and wonderful memories. I hope June and Rachel enjoyed their first trick-or-treating adventure with you, and that you encountered only friendly neighbours!

And...result! In the same email she offered to put me in touch with someone who could publicise my books so they reached a wider audience. I shall politely decline and see what happens next.

One thing that has struck me, rather happily, is that AI isn’t capable of loyalty. It has no compunction about grassing on itself, sending these suspect emails into spam, and almost joyfully revealing trickery when the right Google question is asked. If a human was behind these, it would be much more complicated and, eventually, more lethal. As happened to me in the 1980s...

I was phoned by a desperate woman from London who was trying to trace her missing daughter. She reminded me that I had written to this girl’s boyfriend, in the Ivory Coast where she was working, offering him more or less a blank cheque for information about his country for a guidebook. My mystification must have been obvious, and I could hear the light dawning on this poor woman. Her daughter had been convinced that this man was going to receive a large amount of money and that had persuaded her to marry him. The mother forwarded me the letter which was indeed signed by ‘Hilary Bradt’ on convincing headed note paper but needless to say entirely fictitious.

Just recalling this makes me sad.

And that’s the thing. No doubt humans have used deception for personal gain since the first grunts of communication, but these days trust is in such short supply. We are warned to be suspicious of everyone, especially if their motive seems to be simple kindness.

Such a shame.

Until next time,

Hilary

Bradt Guides
31a High Street
Chesham
Buckinghamshire
HP5 1BW
United Kingdom
​
info@bradtguides.com​

This email was sent to Reader
You received this email because you are registered with Bradt Guides Ltd.

​Unsubscribe here​

Bradt Guides Ltd

Read more from Bradt Guides Ltd

Happy Sunday! This week, all eyes are on the website, with the publication of two brand-new articles exploring historic places in Scotland that you might not know about (but really should), alongside another highlighting five unique sites that offer an insight into Britain and Ireland’s rich Muslim heritage. Plus, we take a look at some of England’s most bizarre Bonfire Night traditions, including unusual local customs and celebrations with a surprising twist. Finally, a friendly reminder...

October in Review October has been another eventful month here at Bradt! There’s just one week left to enter our 2027 New Travel Writer of the Year Competition, so if you’ve been thinking about putting pen to paper, now’s the time! This year’s theme is ‘An Animal Encounter’, with a five-night South African adventure for two up for grabs. We’ve continued our journey through Africa’s finest safari destinations, sharing more of our picks for the continent’s best wildlife experiences, from the...

Hello, This week, we're encouraging you to plan your next adventure to Angola on the Bradt App, exploring its wild coastlines, tropical rainforests and vibrant cities. Closer to home, discover our new article on Kent’s wild places, celebrating the county’s natural beauty and wildlife. From our Best Safaris round-up, we’re highlighting South Africa and Uganda, two incredible destinations for unforgettable wildlife encounters. Finally, don’t forget to enter our New Travel Writer of the Year...